The Technique of Skin Stretching for Acute Burn Treatment and Scar Reconstruction
A randomized controlled trial is performed to evaluate the clinical effectiveness of the skin stretching technique for two categories:
- acute burn wounds: wound closure by means of skin stretching should lead to a significant reduction of scar surface area in comparison to the standard technique, the split skin grafting;
- scar reconstructions: wound closure by means of skin stretching during one operative procedure should lead to a comparable scar surface in comparison to the multiple procedures techniques such as serial excision.
Skin stretching will be compared to split skin grafting and should result in burn wound closure with significantly smaller scars. Also, a comparison will be made between the technique of serial excision versus skin stretching for scar reconstructions.
Scar evaluation three and twelve months after surgery will include the following parameters:
- surface area;
- Patient and Observer Scar Assessment Scale (POSAS);
- vascularization and pigmentation;
- dermal architecture.
After 12 months adults will undergo a biopsy of the scar under local anesthesia. The experimental group, treated with the skin stretcher will undergo one extra biopsy of the formerly stretched skin.
At the start of the operation will be determined by randomization if skin stretching or split skin grafting (acute burn wounds) or serial excision (scar reconstruction category) will be performed.
|Burns Scars||Procedure: Split skin graft Procedure: skin stretching device Procedure: serial excision||Phase 3|
|Study Design:||Allocation: Randomized
Intervention Model: Parallel Assignment
Masking: Open Label
Primary Purpose: Treatment
|Official Title:||The Technique of Skin Stretching for Acute Burn Treatment and Scar Reconstruction: Clinical Applications and Working Mechanisms.|
- the surface area of the scar after 12 months [ Time Frame: 3 and 12 months after surgery ]
- scar evaluation protocol: - patient and observer scar assessment scale (POSAS); - scar elasticity (Cutometer); - scar vascularization & pigmentation (DermaSpectrometer); - scar thickness [ Time Frame: 3 and 12 months after surgery ]
|Study Start Date:||December 2007|
|Study Completion Date:||June 2011|
|Primary Completion Date:||June 2011 (Final data collection date for primary outcome measure)|
Active Comparator: A1
Acute Burn Wounds: Wound debridement and split skin grafting
Procedure: Split skin graft
After wound bed preparation the skin defect is covered with a skin transplant (split skin graft)
Acute Burn Wounds: excision of the burn wound and primary closure, using a skin stretching device
Procedure: skin stretching device
after woundbed preparation the wound is primarily closed by aid of the skin stretching device
Active Comparator: B1
Scar reconstruction: serial excision
Procedure: serial excision
as much scar as possible is excised, whereafter the wound is closed
Scar reconstruction: primary closure, using skin stretching device
Procedure: skin stretching device
after the scar is excised, the wound is primarily closed by aid of the skin stretching device
1. Acute Burn wounds or scar reconstructions that require surgical treatment; 2. Sufficient healthy skin at (at least) one edge of the wound/scar must be available for the stretching procedure.
3. Age >= 18 years
- language barrier;
- known history of keloid formation;
- systemic diseases: Diabetes Mellitus, immunodeficiency, arterial insufficiency;
- local or systemic application of corticosteroids;
- psychiatric diseases leading to study bias (e.g. automutilation);
- skin diseases that lead to collagen and/or elastin abnormalities such as Ehlers Danlos;
- radiated skin;
- wound located at extremities, exceeding >33% of circumference (acute burn category);
Primary study parameters/outcome of the study:
The primary study parameter is the surface area of the scar after 12 months
Secondary study parameters/outcome of the study (if applicable):
All scars will also be subjected to the scar evaluation protocol after 3 and 12 months by an independent observer for the evaluation of the:
- patient and observer scar assessment scale (POSAS);
- scar elasticity (Cutometer);
- scar vascularisation & pigmentation (DermaSpectrometer);
- scar thickness (histopathology, only after 12 months).
Punch biopsies are taken for morphometry of dermal architecture (Fourier analysis). During surgery one biopsy is obtained of the normal skin. In the experimental group an additional biopsy is obtained at the end of the stretching procedure in order to be able to compare structure of the dermal matrix and orientation of the collagen fibers.
After 1 year, one biopsy is taken from the scar. The experimental group will undergo one additional biopsy of the formerly stretched skin.
Please refer to this study by its ClinicalTrials.gov identifier: NCT00609908
|Red Cross Hospital|
|Principal Investigator:||E Middelkoop, Professor||VU MC|
|Study Director:||P.P.M. van Zuijlen, MD, PhD||Red Cross Hospital Beverwijk|