The Study of Barrett's Esophagus: What Are the Factors of Progression (BEST)
|ClinicalTrials.gov Identifier: NCT00586404|
Recruitment Status : Terminated (lack of enrollment)
First Posted : January 4, 2008
Last Update Posted : May 30, 2017
|First Submitted Date||December 21, 2007|
|First Posted Date||January 4, 2008|
|Last Update Posted Date||May 30, 2017|
|Actual Study Start Date||November 2007|
|Actual Primary Completion Date||May 2017 (Final data collection date for primary outcome measure)|
|Current Primary Outcome Measures
||To determine the prevalence and incidence of low grade dysplasia, high grade dysplasia and adenocarcinoma in a large cohort of patients with Barrett's esophagus [ Time Frame: up to 10 years ]|
|Original Primary Outcome Measures
||To determine the prevalence and incidence of low grade dysplasia, high grade dysplasia and adenocarcinoma in a large cohort of patients with Barrett's esophagus [ Time Frame: prospectively ]|
|Change History||Complete list of historical versions of study NCT00586404 on ClinicalTrials.gov Archive Site|
|Current Secondary Outcome Measures
||To determine the magnitude of the contribution of selected factors (e.g. age, gender, ethnicity, obesity, tobacco use, alcohol use, ASA/NSAID/PPI use, duration of GERD symptoms, length of BE, HH) to the risk of HGD and CA [ Time Frame: up to 10 years ]|
|Original Secondary Outcome Measures
||To determine the magnitude of the contribution of selected factors (e.g. age, gender, ethnicity, obesity, tobacco use, alcohol use, ASA/NSAID/PPI use, duration of GERD symptoms, length of BE, HH) to the risk of HGD and CA [ Time Frame: prospectively ]|
|Current Other Outcome Measures||Not Provided|
|Original Other Outcome Measures||Not Provided|
|Brief Title||The Study of Barrett's Esophagus: What Are the Factors of Progression|
|Official Title||Barrett's Esophagus Study (BEST) Trial - a Multi-Center and Endoscopic Outcomes Project|
|Brief Summary||This trial is a multi-center clinical and endoscopic outcomes project involving a single large database of patients with Barrett's Esophagus (BE). The initial goal of this project is to define the incidence and prevalence of cancer and high-grade dysplasia (HGD) in patients with BE. Thus, our hypothesis is that systematic collection of data on the natural history of BE and risk factors for progression of BE will provide useful information to develop a decision model for risk stratification and risk reduction strategies in BE.|
Barrett's esophagus (BE) is defined as a change in the esophageal mucosa from normal squamous epithelium to columnar epithelium with intestinal metaplasia (1). There is compelling evidence that BE is a precursor lesion for adenocarcinoma of the esophagus (2). There is also evidence that the prevalence of BE is much higher than was initially suspected, and that the true incidence rate of cancer in patients with BE is much lower than previously estimated. Endoscopic surveillance of all patients with BE is not likely to be cost effective, or save many lives. Therefore, it is important to understand which patients with BE are likely to progress to malignancy, and equally important to determine which patients are not likely to progress.Because progression is an uncommon event, definitive studies of natural history including evaluation of numerous risk factors require large numbers of patients, that can only be accomplished in the context of a multicenter study. This model will be a useful tool leading to a reduction in overall health care costs.
An Opportunity to Generate the Essential Knowledge for Intervention. We have established an initial network of investigators interested in the 'Barrett's Esophagus Study' (a long term, longitudinal, prospective study) and collected preliminary data in patients with BE. To date, 1376 patients from 4 centers have been entered into a central databank. We have presented preliminary data on the incidence and prevalence rates of high-grade dysplasia and cancer at national meetings. We now propose the creation of a formal consortium to perform a cohort study with the ultimate primary aim of defining risk factors for the development of high-grade dysplasia and adenocarcinoma in patients with BE. Such a multi-center, prospective, cohort, multi-disciplinary approach to BE was endorsed by the "NIH PRG on stomach and esophageal cancers" (May 2002).
BACKGROUND & CLINICAL SIGNIFICANCE Barrett's Esophagus the pre-malignant lesion for esophageal adenocarcinoma - a Condition of Rapidly Increasing Incidence. Patients with BE are at an increased risk for the development of esophageal adenocarcinoma and esophagogastric junction adenocarcinoma. Adenocarcinoma of the esophagus is believed to arise from BE in a step-wise progression from low-grade dysplasia to high-grade dysplasia, finally leading to frank adenocarcinoma (4,5). The cost effectiveness of surveillance endoscopy in patients with BE is very sensitive to the incidence of cancer (11). The exact incidence of adenocarcinoma in patients with BE is not known and has been reported to vary from 1 in 50 patient-years of follow up to 1 in 285 patient-years of follow up (18-22). The published incidence data from existing cohorts of patients with BE have been influenced by the small number of patients being evaluated, short duration of follow-up as well as by the demographics of the population being studied (e.g. older patients, male sex). To date, the maximum number of patients included in a published study determining the incidence of adenocarcinoma has been only 327 patients (23,24). The ultimate goal of the proposed study is to establish a large cohort of patients with BE to address issues of incidence, progression and risk factors influencing progression. Such an approach was recently endorsed by the "NIH 2002 PRG on stomach and esophageal cancers".
Factors predicting the development of dysplasia and cancer in BE patients are unknown. A few possible factors have been associated with esophageal adenocarcinoma, but not studied in BE patients. These include GERD symptoms, obesity, diet, smoking, prior cholecystectomy, drugs and H pylori infection (negative association) (25-36). The presence of hiatal hernia and BE length have been associated with dysplasia and cancer development in BE patients in a preliminary single center study (37). Reflux symptoms have also been reported to be significantly more prevalent among parents and siblings of patients with BE and esophageal adenocarcinoma than spouse control relatives (38). A few uncontrolled reports have provided conflicting results on the role of anti-reflux surgery and the use of acid suppressive medications (proton pump inhibitors, H2 receptor antagonists) and their effect on the neoplastic progression in BE patients (39-43). However, all the studies to date in BE patients have been limited by small sample sizes, univariate analysis, short duration of follow-up, lack of adjustment for confounding variables etc. In this proposed study, risk factors and mechanisms of capturing data at each site and data transfer to the main study database will be discussed and implemented. Sample size calculations for appropriate univariate and multiple logistic regression analysis will be performed.
Proposed Study will Fill Significant Gaps in Knowledge. In the recent "NIH PRG on stomach and esophageal cancers (May 2002)" and a workshop sponsored by the NIH & The American Digestive Health Foundation on endoscopic priorities (44), experts in the field acknowledged that there was a need for multi-center, longitudinal, studies and there were significant gaps in the knowledge base of BE including:
The information gained will be clinically useful. We will define the natural history of progression of BE patients and to determine factors involved in this progression to high-grade dysplasia and cancer. The potentially unique answers obtained from the study would have major clinical relevance in
PRELIMINARY STUDIES At this time, preliminary data have been collected from the 4 participating centers, and merged into one single databank. These preliminary results were presented at the plenary sessions (45,46) of the American Gastroenterological Association (AGA) annual meeting in Atlanta, GA (May 2001) and at the American College of Gastroenterology (ACG) annual meeting in Las Vegas, NV (October 2001), indicating a common interest amongst the investigators and capability of working together.
Distribution of Degree of Dysplasia. From the four participating centers, 1376 patients have met the study criteria and had at least one endoscopy with biopsy revealing intestinal metaplasia, thus confirming the diagnosis of BE. At the initial endoscopy, the distribution of dysplasia was as follows:
Diagnosis Number of pts. Prevalence Low-grade dysplasia (LGD) 101 7.3% High-grade dysplasia (HGD) 42 3% Esophageal adenocarcinoma 91 6.7% Incidence and progression to low-grade dysplasia, high-grade dysplasia and esophageal adenocarcinoma. 1376 patients were enrolled in the prevalence phase of the study. To date, 618 patients (95% Caucasians, 14% Females) have had follow-up endoscopic procedures to examine the incidence of dysplasia/cancer. They have been followed for a total of 2546 patient-years; mean follow up 4.12 patient-years (range: 1-22.5 yrs). Twelve patients developed cancer during follow up for a cancer incidence of 1 in 212 patient-years of follow up or 0.5% per year. The mean time to development of cancer was 5.3 yrs (range: 2.4-11.2 yrs). Of interest, 7 of 12 patients had high-grade dysplasia before cancer development while 2 had only low-grade dysplasia; 3 developed cancer from BE without dysplasia documented at any point. 22 patients developed high-grade dysplasia during follow up for an estimate of high-grade dysplasia incidence of 1 in 116 patient-years of follow up or 0.9% per year. The mean time to high-grade dysplasia development was 3.8 yrs (range: 1.2-7.9 yrs). 11 of 22 patients developed high-grade dysplasia from BE without documented dysplasia, whereas the remaining 11 went from low-grade dysplasia to high-grade dysplasia.
Risk Factors for BE and adenocarcinoma. The epidemiology and natural history of BE has been poorly studied. Some factors have been associated with an increased risk for esophageal adenocarcinoma in the general population (see Table 1), but risk factors for progression in BE patients are not clear. A number of risk factors have been suggested as factors of risk in BE patients including age, gender, ethnicity, GERD symptoms, family history of BE/cancer, alcohol, tobacco, dietary factors (fat intake, cereal fiber, calcium etc.) acid suppressive medications, biomarkers, genetic markers etc. Given this long list of possible risk factors, we propose to convene a panel of experts in a planning committee to serve as jury in order to determine which of the potential risk factors should be measured in a prospective study and how they should be measured. This would narrow and refine the list of risk factors for the prospective study.
There are a lot of purported risk factors to be evaluated. Thus, there is a long list (see below) of potential factors of risk in patients with BE associated with progression to dysplasia and/or cancer:
(1) Age (2) Gender (3) Ethnicity (4) Reflux symptoms (5) Smoking (6) Alcohol (7) Dietary fat (8) Dietary fiber, vegetables, fruits (9) Dietary calcium (10) Obesity (11) Family history of reflux, BE or esophageal cancer (12) Use of aspirin, non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (13) Use of lower esophageal sphincter relaxing medications (14) Use of acid suppressive medications (15) Cholecystectomy (16) Anti-reflux surgery (fundoplication) (17) Length of BE (18) Hiatal hernia (19) Helicobacter pylori infection (20) Low-grade dysplasia on biopsy This proposal will make it feasible to narrow on the factors to be studied in the prospective trial.
Statistical Analysis Prevalence and incidence rates: We expect to increase the baseline-screened population from 1376 to more than 2500 individuals in the final study. The number of patients we expect to enroll each year will be calculated and the expected number of new prevalence cases using the 9.7% prevalence rate with the preliminary study data will be estimated. In the preliminary study to date 618 patients have had at least one follow-up visit. Including the remaining 700 patients from the preliminary study and assuming a 10% rate for loss to follow up, we will have 6100-7450 patient years of follow up. The expected number of new incidence cases using the 1.3% incidence rate with the preliminary study data will be estimated.
|Study Design||Observational Model: Cohort
Time Perspective: Prospective
|Target Follow-Up Duration||Not Provided|
|Sampling Method||Probability Sample|
|Study Population||Patients who have histologically confirmed Barrett's Esophagus|
Patients with confirmed Barrett's Esophagus
* Includes publications given by the data provider as well as publications identified by ClinicalTrials.gov Identifier (NCT Number) in Medline.
|Original Estimated Enrollment
|Actual Study Completion Date||May 2017|
|Actual Primary Completion Date||May 2017 (Final data collection date for primary outcome measure)|
|Ages||18 Years to 80 Years (Adult, Senior)|
|Accepts Healthy Volunteers||Yes|
|Contacts||Contact information is only displayed when the study is recruiting subjects|
|Listed Location Countries||United States|
|Removed Location Countries|
|Other Study ID Numbers||PS0048|
|Has Data Monitoring Committee||Yes|
|U.S. FDA-regulated Product||Not Provided|
|IPD Sharing Statement||Not Provided|
|Responsible Party||PRATEEK SHARMA, Midwest Biomedical Research Foundation|
|Study Sponsor||Midwest Biomedical Research Foundation|
|PRS Account||Midwest Biomedical Research Foundation|
|Verification Date||May 2017|