AMBU AScope2 Fiberoptic Intubation Versus Fastrach Intubating LMA
Device: AMBU Aura-I/aScope 2
Device: LMA Fastrach Single Use
|Study Design:||Allocation: Randomized
Intervention Model: Parallel Assignment
Masking: Open Label
|Official Title:||Flexible Optical Intubation Via the AMBU Aura-I Versus Blind Intubation Via the Fastrach Single Use Intubating LMA - A Prospective Randomized Clinical Trial|
- Total Intubation Time [ Time Frame: Duration of Intubation, including supraglottic airway (SGA) insertion and endotracheal tube (ETT) insertion ]Total Intubation Time includes time for SGA insertion and for ETT insertion. The total time to intubation was measured from the beginning of SGA insertion to successful endotracheal tube intubation verified by detection of CO2 on the capnogram.
- Time for Supraglottic Airway (SGA) Insertion [ Time Frame: At SGA insertion ]Time for SGA insertion was measured from when the tip of the cuff was at the mouth to detection of CO2 on the capnogram.
- Time for Endotracheal Tube (ETT) Insertion [ Time Frame: At ETT insertion ]After the SGA is inserted, time for intubation will be recorded. Time for ETT insertion was measured, for arm 1, from when the AMBU aScope is at the connector level of the Aura-I or, for arm 2, from when the ETT is at the connector level of the Intubating LMA to first detection of CO2 on the capnogram. The AScope 2 disposable fiberoptic camera will be used to assist with intubation for Group 1 patients. Group 2 patients will be intubated using the LMA-Fastrach EndoTracheal Tube.
- Number of Participants in Whom SGA Insertion Was Successful on the First Attempt [ Time Frame: At SGA insertion ]
- Number of Participants in Whom ETT Insertion Was Successful on the First Attempt [ Time Frame: At ETT insertion ]
- Number of Participants With Overall Success for SGA Placement [ Time Frame: At SGA insertion ]Ease of SGA insertion is subjectively assessed by the operator on a scale from 1 to 5 (1 = extremely easy, 5 = extremely difficult).
- Number of Participants With Overall Intubation Success [ Time Frame: At ETT insertion ]Ease of ETT insertion is subjectively assessed by the operator on a scale from 1 to 5 (1 = extremely easy, 5 = extremely difficult).
- Post-Operative Discomfort Upon Entering the Post-Anesthesia Care Unit (PACU) [ Time Frame: Within 30 minutes of completion of surgery ]The patient will be assessed for Post-Operative Hoarseness, Sore Mouth, Sore Neck, Sore Jaw, Dysphonia, Dysphagia, and Altered Tongue Sensation.
- Post-Operative Discomfort Upon Leaving the Post-Anesthesia Care Unit (PACU) [ Time Frame: Approximately 1-2 hours after entering the PACU ]The patient will be assessed for Post-Operative Hoarseness, Sore Mouth, Sore Neck, Sore Jaw, Dysphonia, Dysphagia, and Altered Tongue Sensation.
- Orolaryngeal Pressure [ Time Frame: Following SGA Insertion ]The oropharyngeal leak pressure (OLP) was determined by closing the expiratory valve of the circle system at a fixed gas flow of 3 L/min and noting the airway pressure at which equilibrium was reached (not permitted to exceed 40 cm H2O).
|Study Start Date:||July 2010|
|Study Completion Date:||January 2013|
|Primary Completion Date:||January 2013 (Final data collection date for primary outcome measure)|
Experimental: AMBU Aura-I/aScope 2
First, the AMBU Aura-I LMA will be inserted. Then, the patient will be intubated with assistance of the AMBU aScope 2 disposable fiberoptic system.
Device: AMBU Aura-I/aScope 2
Once ventilation is achieved, the patients in group A will be intubated through the shaft of Aura-I via the the Ambu aScope.
Experimental: LMA Fastrach
The LMA Fastrach Single Use Laryngeal Mask Airway will be placed, followed by blind intubation using the LMA Fastrach EndoTracheal Tube.
Device: LMA Fastrach Single Use
The patients in group B will be intubated by ETT via the Intubating LMA as is standard procedure.
The study will include a total of 66 patients. Patients will be randomized into 2 groups through a computer generated randomization schedule. Patients in group A (N= 30) will be intubated using Ambu Aura-I and the Ambu aScope and patients in group B (N= 30) will be intubated using Intubating LMA. Patients will only be tested with one device.In the operating room, standard monitoring devices will be applied including a pulse oximeter, 3 lead (at least) ECG and blood pressure cuff; the latter could be invasive or non-invasive depending on the nature of the surgery. Baseline measures of BP, pulse, oxygen saturation, and CO2 will be made. The time will be noted before any sedation or anesthesia is administered. Vital signs will be recorded after induction of anesthesia, after insertion of SGA, and again after successful intubation.
General anesthesia will be induced by bolus administration of propofol (1.5 to 2mg/kg) and fentanyl (1mcg/kg), and maintained with an inhalational agent. Rocuronium (0.6 mg/kg) will be administered to provide muscle relaxation and a mixture of sevoflurane or isoflurane and nitrous oxide will be utilized for maintenance of anesthesia once the ability to mask ventilate is confirmed. The lungs will be mechanically ventilated with a semi-closed circle system to maintain an end-tidal CO2 near 35 mmHg. Patients' lungs will be ventilated via anesthesia mask 100% oxygen until the patient is completely relaxed.
The size of the SGA device used will be based on manufacturer's recommendations and clinical evaluation of the anesthesiologist. The SGA device will be placed using standard technique and jaw lift will always be performed to aid in placement. The user will record ease of insertion on a scale (1-5) and number of insertions required will also be recorded. A new attempt is considered to begin if the tip of the cuff is withdrawn to the level of the lips. Accurate ventilation is achieved when the CO2 signal is rectangular and the mask is airtight at a respiratory pressure of up to 20 cm H2O. Time will be recorded from when the tip of the device cuff is at the mouth opening and stopped when first CO2 waveform is recorded.
Once ventilation is achieved, the patients in group A will be intubated through the shaft of Aura-I via the the Ambu aScope. If the epiglottis is down folded and obscuring optical view, jaw lift can be performed by an assistant to improve visualization of the cords. The aScope will be advanced until the carina is visualized and then the ETT is railroaded via the aScope into position (5cm above carina or cuff of ETT just below vocal cords). Once the ETT is successfully inserted, the cuff of the Aura-I will be deflated and the patient is ventilated via the ETT. If it is not possible to intubate, the ETT should be rotated 90° counterclockwise and jaw lift should be performed to help with intubation. If unsuccessful after two attempts, the anesthesiologist will proceed to intubate in standard fashion. The patients in group B will be intubated by ETT via the Intubating LMA as is standard procedure.
Once the procedure has finished and the patient is adequately reversed as determined by nerve stimulation, the cuff will be reinflated and the ETT will be removed. Ventilation will resume via the SGA. Once the ETT is withdrawn, the cuff will be adjusted to 60cm H2O using a cuff pressure manometer. The oropharyngeal leak pressure(OLP) is determined with a 60 cm H2O intracuff pressure by closing the expiratory spill valve and then closing the expiratory valve of the circle system at a fixed gas flow of 3 L/min, without any respiration. The airway pressure at which equilibrium is reached and air leaks from the mouth or into the stomach, as sign of leak of the laryngeal mask is noted. Esophageal leak is determined by stethoscopy of the epigastrium and oropharyngeal leak is dectected listening for air leak over the mouth.
The peak airway pressure is not allowed to exceed 40 cmH2O. After OLP measurement and once the patient is adequately breathing on their own, the SGA can be removed.
Please refer to this study by its ClinicalTrials.gov identifier: NCT01656967
|United States, Texas|
|Memorial Hermann Hospital - Texas Medical Center|
|Houston, Texas, United States, 77030|
|Principal Investigator:||Carin A Hagberg, MD||The University of Texas Medical School at Houston|