Trial of exSALT SD7™ Compared to Xeroform® Petrolatum Dressing for the Management of Partial Thickness Donor Sites
Recruitment status was: Recruiting
This randomized, controlled trial is designed to evaluate split-thickness donor sites treated with exSALT SD7™ compared to donor sites treated with Xeroform®. For the purpose of this study, subjects enrolled will have selected donor sites or portions of donor sites designated as "Test Sites." The selected locations will be randomly assigned treatment with either the Test Dressing or the Control Dressing.
The primary objective of the trial will be to quantify the proportion of the donor sites in each group that are healed at 10 and 14 days. Secondary objectives will include: time to re-epithelialization, pain with dressing changes and mobilization, ease of use, resource utilization and safety, as well as quality of healing and overall cosmetic result. A total of 25 subjects will be enrolled in the trial.
The trial duration will be 12 weeks. For the purposes of this trial, healing will be defined as ≥ 90% re-epithelialization and must be visually confirmed by the investigator or designate and two other people (i.e., research nurse, burn resident, member of the Wound Care Team). The maximum time to evaluate healing will be 14 days +/-2 days. A final visit will be conducted at 12 weeks for safety and to evaluate the quality of healing.
|Wound Healing Wound Infection||Device: The exSALT™ SD7 Wound Dressing Device: Xeroform® Petrolatum Dressing|
|Study Design:||Allocation: Randomized
Intervention Model: Parallel Assignment
Masking: Open Label
Primary Purpose: Treatment
|Official Title:||A Randomized, Site-Matched, Controlled Trial of exSALT SD7™ Compared to Xeroform® Petrolatum Dressing for the Management of Partial Thickness Donor Sites|
- Evaluate the proportion of donor sites healed. [ Time Frame: 10 days ]
- Evaluate the proportion of donor sites healed. [ Time Frame: 14 Days ]
- Time to re-epithelialization. [ Time Frame: 12 weeks ]
- Pain with dressing changes and mobilization. [ Time Frame: 12 weeks ]
- Assessments that quantify ease of use. [ Time Frame: 12 weeks ]
- Resource utilization and safety. [ Time Frame: 12 weeks ]
- Appearance and long term cosmetic results. [ Time Frame: 12 weeks ]
|Study Start Date:||December 2009|
|Estimated Study Completion Date:||January 2011|
|Estimated Primary Completion Date:||December 2010 (Final data collection date for primary outcome measure)|
Experimental: exSALT SD7™ Wound Dressing
The exSALT™ SD7 Wound Dressing provides an antimicrobial barrier that inhibits microbial growth in the dressing. The exSALT™ SD7 Wound Dressing consists of 3 layers: two non-adherent polyethylene mesh wound contact layers and one absorbent core made of polyester. All three layers are silver coated. The concentration of silver on the exSALT™ SD7 Wound Dressing is approximately 0.4 mg/cm2 (2.5% w/w).
Device: The exSALT™ SD7 Wound Dressing
The exSALT™ SD7 Wound Dressing is indicated for the management of partial and full thickness wounds, including decubitus ulcers, venous stasis ulcers, diabetic ulcers, first and second degree burns, grafts and donor sites, or other acute or chronic wounds. The dressing may be used over debrided and grafted wounds.
Other Name: K083870
Active Comparator: Xeroform® Petrolatum Dressing
Xeroform® Petrolatum Dressing (Xeroform® / Control Dressing) is fine mesh gauze impregnated with 3% Bismuth Tribromophenate in a special petrolatum blend. The dressing is a non adherent dressing that clings and conforms to all body parts.
Device: Xeroform® Petrolatum Dressing
Sterile, single use, non-adherent dressing consisting of absorbent gauze impregnated with Xeroform in a petrolatum blend.
Other Name: K973507
Autologous skin grafting is a common procedure required in the care of burn and plastic surgery patients where the harvesting of autologous skin grafts results in the creation of a partial thickness wound known as a donor site. The donor site healing time can affect the length of hospitalization and subject survival.
The literature reports the use of a variety of donor site dressing materials including fine mesh gauze, polyurethane film, synthetic fiber and hydrocolloids (Kilinc, Sensoz et al. 2001). The literature reports what might be considered the optimal donor site dressing attributes. These attributes would include: minimizing pain, velocity in healing, minimizing bacterial growth and simplicity in use (Rakel, Bermel et al. 1998).
However, none of the available dressing products are entirely satisfactory. Fine mesh gauze (FMG) is the donor site dressing used at many burn centers, as it is inexpensive, can be placed on posterior donor sites, does not require a margin of intact skin and allows large amounts of exudate to drain away from the donor site.
However, FMG does not have any inherent anti-infective properties and provides a dry environment for wound healing. Xeroform® Petrolatum Dressing resembles FMG physically except that it contains 3% xeroform (bismuth tribromophenate) which exerts some antibacterial effect (Feldman, Rogers et al. 1991). Xeroform® Petrolatum Dressing is the standard donor site dressing in the Firefighters' Burn Treatment Unit (3C2 WMC) and Plastic Surgery Unit (3D3 WMC) and has been selected as the control treatment (Control Dressing).
Research evidence demonstrates that partial thickness wounds re-epithelialize more rapidly in a moist environment that is free from infection (Alper 1986; Alvarez 1988). In an effort to provide an improved method of dressing wounds and donor sites, exSALT SD7™ has been proposed as an alternative dressing (Test Dressing). The dressing is intended to reduce pain and discomfort and improve the re-epithelialization process by providing a moist environment. The model outlined in this protocol provides the basis for a controlled comparison of wound healing and re-epithelialization in a clean partial thickness wound that allows us to compare the healing rate and quality of the Test Dressing compared to our standard of care to determine safety and efficacy.
Please refer to this study by its ClinicalTrials.gov identifier: NCT00968994
|Contact: John Simon, BSc||780-248-5884||JSimon@Excitontech.com|
|Contact: Heather Shankowsky, RN||780-407-3408||Heather.Shankowsky@albertahealthservices.ca|
|The University of Alberta Hospital||Recruiting|
|Edmonton, Alberta, Canada, T6G 2B7|
|Contact: Heather Shankowsky, RN 780-407-3408 Heather.Shankowsky@albertahealthservices.ca|
|Contact: Edward E Tredget, MD, MSC 780-407-6979 email@example.com|
|Principal Investigator: Edward E Tredget, MD, MSc|
|Sub-Investigator: Timothy M Riegel, MD|
|Study Director:||Ruth Collins-Nakai, MD, MBA||Exciton Technologies Inc.|
|Principal Investigator:||Edward E Tredget, MD, MSc||University of Alberta|