Cortical Comminution and Intra-articular Involvement in Distal Radius Fractures Can Predict Radiological Outcome. A Prospective Multicenter Study

This study has been completed.
Sponsor:
Information provided by (Responsible Party):
Sundsvall Hospital
ClinicalTrials.gov Identifier:
NCT01778673
First received: January 24, 2013
Last updated: NA
Last verified: January 2013
History: No changes posted
  Purpose

Background: Although fractures of the distal radius are the most common skeletal injury, the utility of the available classification systems to predict fracture stability is limited. We studied if cortical comminution and intra-articular involvement can assess instability in fractures of the distal radius.

Methods: A prospective multicenter study was conducted. Distal radius fractures in 417 skeletally mature patients (428 fractures) were studied. Fractures were divided into osteoporotic or non-osteoporotic according to age of the patients. Antero-posterior and lateral plain radiographs determined if the fractures were minimally displaced or displaced. The fracture patterns were evaluated depending on the presence and the site of cortical comminution and intra-articular involvement according to a new classification system (Buttazzoni classification). Minimally displaced fractures were treated with cast immobilization. Displaced fractures underwent closed reduction with subsequent cast immobilization. Radiographs were obtained after reduction, at 10-14 days and after 3 months. Displacement was classified as primary instability, secondary instability or late instability. Endpoints were union of the fracture or re-displacement. Results: Volarly comminuted fractures (Buttazzoni 4) displaced in 96 %, intra-articular fractures (Buttazzoni 3) in 72%, dorsally comminuted fractures (Buttazzoni 2) in 73% and non-comminuted (Buttazzoni 1) in 16 % of the cases. One third of the initially minimally displaced fractures did not maintain acceptable alignment. All initially displaced volarly comminuted fractures were unstable. In both initially displaced and minimally displaced fractures, cortical comminution and intra-articular involvement were predictive for primary, secondary and late instability.

Conclusions: Cortical comminution and intra-articular involvement seem to be valuable instruments for assessing stability at initial presentation of distal radius fractures. Level of Evidence: Level I, prospective multicenter study. Prognostic study.


Condition Intervention
Distal Radius Fracture
Radiological Outcome
Procedure: Cast immobilization

Study Type: Observational
Study Design: Observational Model: Cohort
Time Perspective: Prospective

Resource links provided by NLM:


Further study details as provided by Sundsvall Hospital:

Primary Outcome Measures:
  • Fracture displacement [ Time Frame: 3 months ] [ Designated as safety issue: No ]

Study Start Date: October 2009
Primary Completion Date: September 2011 (Final data collection date for primary outcome measure)
Groups/Cohorts Assigned Interventions
Distal radius fractures Sundsvall Hospital Procedure: Cast immobilization
Distal radius fractures Östersund Hospital. Procedure: Cast immobilization

Detailed Description:

Between the 1st of October 2009 and the 30th of September 2011 patients with DRF at two teaching hospitals were invited to participate in a prospective study. Patients between 15 and 74 years, with closed physes of the distal radius and ulna were included. Exclusion criteria were dementia, previous fracture to the ipsilateral wrist, open fracture, other concomitant or existing damage or injury to the wrist, Galeazzi fracture, rheumatoid arthritis, alcohol or drug abuse and neurologic impairment. All patients underwent radiographic examination with frontal and lateral views centered on the wrist in neutral rotation. The radiographs were classified by the doctor on-call who had the needed information about the classification system available.

Undisplaced or minimally displaced fractures (will be called minimally displaced throughout this article) were immobilized in a Plaster-of-Paris (PoP) slab from distal to the elbow to proximal to the MCP-joints with the wrist in a neutral position. Displaced fractures were reduced under hematoma-block local anesthesia, immobilized with PoP slab and then radiologically re-examined. In cases of re-displacement at post-reduction x-ray, the fractures were registered as primary instability and further treated according to the guidelines of the treating department. Both if the fracture was minimally displaced and if reduction was successful radiographic examination was performed after 10-14 days.

If still acceptable at 10-14 days, the fractures were treated in PoP slab for totally 4-6 weeks. If the fracture at follow up had displaced, it was registered as secondary instability and further treatment was discussed. After 3 or more months radiographs were again obtained to confirm union and final position of the fracture. Fractures with an acceptable position at 10-14 days which later mal-united were registered as late instability.

If reduction to an acceptable position was not achieved initially or was lost at the 10-14 days control this was considered to be the end-point for this particular fracture in this study. Thus all fractures that entered and finished this study can either be considered to have been stable i.e. went to union in an acceptable position without operation, or were fractures that at one point or another showed that they were so unstable that an acceptable position could not be established or kept with conservative means.

Acceptable position To define acceptable and non-acceptable positions we used specific radiographic criteria. We measured volar inclination, radial tilt, ulnar variance and any eventual intra-articular step-off. It is considered that elderly people tolerate more displacement than younger people (6,10). Some authors have made an arbitrary definition, considering females above 49 years and males above 59 years as osteoporotic. Therefore; we have divided the patients into two groups, one "younger" below and one "elderly" above these ages.

For the "elderly" we accepted volar inclination up to 20°, dorsal tilt up to 10° and radial tilt of 10° or more. For the "younger" we accepted volar inclination up to 15°, dorsal tilt up to 10° and radial tilt of 15° or more. Up to 2 mm. of ulnar variance and less than 2 mm. of intra-articular step-off were acceptable in both groups.

Statistics The Fischer's exact test was used to compare each pair of class. To correct for multiple comparisons the p-values from the Fischer's exact test was corrected with Benjamini Hochberg correction. IBM SPSS 20 was used for most analysis, except for the Fischer exact with the correction where R, version 2.15 (http://www.r-project.org), was used with package fmsb. A p-value <0.05 is considered statistically significant. The false-discovery-rate for the Benjamini-Hochberg correction was set as 0.05.

  Eligibility

Ages Eligible for Study:   15 Years to 74 Years
Genders Eligible for Study:   Both
Accepts Healthy Volunteers:   No
Sampling Method:   Probability Sample
Study Population

community sample

Criteria

Inclusion Criteria:

  • Patients with distal radius fracture between 15 and 74 years, with closed physes of the distal radius and ulna.

Exclusion Criteria:

  • Dementia, previous fracture to the ipsilateral wrist, open fracture, other concomitant or existing damage or injury to the wrist, Galeazzi fracture, rheumatoid arthritis, alcohol or drug abuse and neurologic impairment.
  Contacts and Locations
Choosing to participate in a study is an important personal decision. Talk with your doctor and family members or friends about deciding to join a study. To learn more about this study, you or your doctor may contact the study research staff using the Contacts provided below. For general information, see Learn About Clinical Studies.

Please refer to this study by its ClinicalTrials.gov identifier: NCT01778673

Locations
Sweden
Department of orthopedic surgery Sundsvall Hospital
Sundsvall, Sweden, 851 86
Sponsors and Collaborators
Sundsvall Hospital
  More Information

No publications provided

Responsible Party: Sundsvall Hospital
ClinicalTrials.gov Identifier: NCT01778673     History of Changes
Other Study ID Numbers: 09-213
Study First Received: January 24, 2013
Last Updated: January 24, 2013
Health Authority: Sweden: Regional Ethical Review Board

Additional relevant MeSH terms:
Fractures, Bone
Radius Fractures
Wounds and Injuries
Forearm Injuries
Arm Injuries

ClinicalTrials.gov processed this record on July 29, 2014