Efficacy of Dual Focus Mutual Aid for Persons With Co-occurring Disorders

• Substance abuse [ Time Frame: Study intake and six month follow-up ] [ Designated as safety issue: No ]
  Self-reported substance use and saliva toxicology for drugs
  
  

• psychiatric medication adherence [ Time Frame: six month follow-up ] [ Designated as safety issue: No ]
  Self-reported adherence to prescribed medications
  
  
• Traditional 12-step meeting participation [ Time Frame: six month follow-up ] [ Designated as safety issue: No ]
  
• Treatment retention [ Time Frame: six month follow-up ] [ Designated as safety issue: No ]
  
• Quality of life [ Time Frame: six month follow-up ] [ Designated as safety issue: No ]
  

This study builds on two previous studies by the principal investigator, which found that participation in an established and growing "dual-focus" mutual aid model (Double Trouble in Recovery; DTR) by persons with co-occurring substance use and psychiatric disorders was associated with drug/alcohol abstinence and improved psychiatric outcomes. However, these findings are limited as they are based on studies using an observational design with existing DTR groups and a pre-post design with a historical control. This new application seeks to confirm and significantly extend this research by conducting a randomized clinical trial (RCT) of DTR at multiple treatment sites.

The specific study aims are:

1. To conduct a multi-site RCT to determine the efficacy of "dual focus" 12-step mutual aid groups for persons with co-occurring substance use and mental disorders. Substance-using patients who are admitted to psychiatric outpatient clinics will be randomly assigned within each clinic to (i) DTR group participation plus standard treatment, or (ii) standard treatment as usual (wait list for DTR). The primary outcome is drug/alcohol use. The secondary outcomes are psychiatric medication adherence; quality of life; treatment retention; and traditional 12 step group participation. Major assessments will occur at baseline and 6 months later.
2. To determine the therapeutic mechanisms mediating between DTR participation and behavioral outcomes. Hypothesized mediating variables will include both "common process" factors across treatments, e.g., coping, self-efficacy and social support; and factors relatively unique to mutual aid, e.g., mutual aid group processes, 12-step attitudes and spirituality.
3. To determine the personal, social/environmental and treatment-related variables which predict DTR affiliation.
4. To describe the development of DTR groups and the conditions needed to sustain them.

Federal substance abuse and mental health policy encourages the use of evidence-based interventions, yet rigorous evaluation data are scant for mutual aid groups. In particular, this research will lead to recommendations for improving the integration of formal treatment with mutual aid for persons with co-occurring disorders. Moreover, by conducting the proposed RCT, the study will substantially raise the standard by which mutual aid is evaluated.