Fibromyalgia Syndrome (FMS) is a chronic pain disorder of unknown origin, characterized by diffuse body pain and tenderness, often accompanied by depression and work disability. Conventional drug and behavioral therapies are often not successful in relieving FMS pain over time. For refractory FMS patients, those with severe, unrelenting pain, opioid maintenance therapy, the current 'last resort' treatment option, can be efficacious, however, it is commonly avoided for fear of addiction. Thus, FMS pain is often unrelieved leading to poor quality of life, disability, and economic disadvantage.
Based on the encouraging results of pre-clinical and clinical research studies suggesting that VNS therapy may target central nervous system (CNS) processes involved in pain transmission at both spinal and supraspinal levels,stimulation of the vagus nerve might reduce pain and improve quality of life. The vagus nerve begins in the brain; it affects the vocal cords, the acid content of the stomach, the heart, the lungs, and other organs. VNS may affect certain regions and chemicals in the brain in a way that may reduce pain symptoms associated with FM. Thus, we believe that VNS therapy could be a viable adjunctive treatment option for patients with refractory FMS. However, in order to proceed toward testing the efficacy of VNS therapy in refractory FMS patients, it is necessary to first determine its tolerability.
Cyberonics, Inc. is the manufacturer of a device that permits long-term vagus nerve stimulation. In order to use this electrical device it needs to be surgically implanted below the collarbone in the same manner as is done with a cardiac pace maker. A wire from the stimulator is then wrapped around the left vagus nerve to allow the nerve to be stimulated. If an FMS patient were to participate, the patient would be in this VNS pilot study for at least one year.
The primary purpose of this pilot study is to determine whether compared to treatment resistant patients with epilepsy and depression, VNS device implantation, ramp-up of stimulation of the vagus nerve, and finally continued stimulation at fixed parameters is as safe and tolerable in a representative sample of patients with severe and unrelenting FMS who may also suffer from depression and can be work disabled.
If VNS therapy is well tolerated by patients with severe and unrelenting FMS, the secondary purpose of this pilot study is to determine the impact of VNS therapy on symptoms of FMS including pain, physical function, mood, as well as quality of life.
Primary Outcome Measures:
- Incidence of adverse events at acute study exit
Secondary Outcome Measures:
- FM 20 multidimensional response index (FM 20)
- Assessment of pain intensity at acute study exit
- Assessment of function at acute study exit
- Assessment of patient global perception at acute study exit
| Estimated Enrollment: |
30 |
| Study Start Date: |
October 2006 |
FMS affects about 4% of the general population and is the second most common rheumatic disease after osteoarthritis. More than 80% of patients in the community with confirmed FMS report that pain is the symptom limiting their ability to work, about one third of patients are work disabled, and approximately 45% collect Social Security Disability insurance. In order to improve these statistics, it is important and necessary to identify a treatment option that will reduce the unrelenting pain in patients with severe FMS. The literature indicates that if severe pain continues unabated, there is an increased probability of functional disability and mood disturbances. Based on our clinical experience, once at this level of FMS 'refractoriness', these patients rarely recover.
We propose VNS therapy as a novel treatment to interrupt the progression from severe to incapacitating pain. However, while safety and tolerability of VNS therapy have been demonstrated in treatment resistant epileptic and depressed patient populations, they have not been established in refractory patients with FMS. Individuals with FMS have generally lower pain thresholds than healthy adults or even patients with epilepsy or depression. Thus, it is possible that the surgical recovery or the ramp up procedure to attain an analgesic response may be more than FMS patients can tolerate. Lack of knowledge as to whether VNS therapy is safe and tolerable for patients with FMS precludes fielding an efficacy study of this promising treatment for FMS at this time. Thus, the overall goal of this pilot study is to provide knowledge about the safety and tolerability of VNS in patients with refractory FMS that must precede the design and implementation of a Phase III trial testing the efficacy of VNS therapy in this population. For the purposes of this pilot study, 'refractory' is operationally defined as failing at least the first 3 levels of a 4 level conventional, pharmacological pain management regimen for FMS, including nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs), tricyclic antidepressants (TCAs), at least two anti epileptic drugs (AEDs), and a short-acting analgesic, Tramadol.
The primary aim of this pilot study is to define the limits of VNS safety and tolerability in patients with refractory FMS following implantation, activation and ramp up, as well as use over an acute study period and follow-up over 24 months post-implantation. We will sample across a representative range of FMS 'refractoriness' that will consist in equal proportions of FMS patients who are work-disabled with concurrent depression, who are working but have concurrent depression, and who are working and free of depression.
The secondary aim of this study, assuming VNS is tolerated, is to assess the impact of VNS therapy on symptoms of FMS (including pain intensity, physical function, patient's global impression of change [FM20], mood, and quality of life, as well as laboratory measures of pain sensitivity). In addition, this study will provide data regarding the range of VNS output current tolerated, the onset, time course, and degree of potential benefit. This information will inform the design of a Phase III trial about "dosing" of stimulation and the minimum duration of a trial that is necessary in these patients.